The Ping Test: Why It's Not a Reliable Way to Authenticate Jade

The Ping Test: Why It's Not a Reliable Way to Authenticate Jade

Jade has a unique combination of physical and optical properties that make it highly desirable, but also difficult to identify and authenticate. One of the most common ways people try to authenticate jade is by using the ping test, but this method is not reliable on it's own and can lead to false conclusions when performed by a non-gemologist.

The ping test is based on the belief that natural jade bangles will emit a clear, high-pitched sound when struck, while all other gemstones will not. According to this theory, the sound or "ping" is caused by the vibration of the jade's crystalline structure.

Here is a video demonstration of The Ping Test:
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/QjlGgen7jKI

However, the truth is that not all natural jade will ping when struck, and not all gemstones will fail the ping test. Natural, unfractured jadeite jade of high quality will indeed emit a clear, musical sound when struck, but natural jade may not ping if fractured or of low quality, or if it's a hinge and clasp bangle. Additionally, dyed green quartz, the most common simulant of jadeite jade, will also ping due to its similar composition and physical properties.

Moreover, the ping test cannot distinguish conclusively between different types of jadeite jade, such as 'A Jade' (natural jade) and 'B Jade' (treated jade), unless a bangle that appears perfectly translucent and unfractured does not ping.

'B Jade,' refers to jadeite that has been acid-bleached and then impregnated with polymer, resin, or wax to enhance its color and translucency. The sonority of the jadeite is interrupted by the polymer inside, so B Jade will not "ping."

It's easy to be misled by a "pinging" sound and assume that the bangle is made of natural, high-quality jadeite jade, when in fact it may just be quartz.

 

If you want to know if your jade is real, send it to Mason-Kay Jade for testing.

Back to blog
  • "Jade in China" Interview with Zemin Luo

    "Jade in China" Interview with Zemin Luo

    Please excuse any errors in this AI-generated transcript. Welcome to Jewels of the Trade. My name is Jordan and I'm here with Zemin  Luo, an independent gem and jewelry appraiser...

    "Jade in China" Interview with Zemin Luo

    Please excuse any errors in this AI-generated transcript. Welcome to Jewels of the Trade. My name is Jordan and I'm here with Zemin  Luo, an independent gem and jewelry appraiser...

  • The Omphacite Dilemma: My Take on "Fei Cui" Nomenclature

    The Omphacite Dilemma: My Take on "Fei Cui" Nom...

    This article has been a long time coming.  Please understand that my views do not represent the views of Mason-Kay Jade, any of their retail partners, or any JOTT Marketing...

    The Omphacite Dilemma: My Take on "Fei Cui" Nom...

    This article has been a long time coming.  Please understand that my views do not represent the views of Mason-Kay Jade, any of their retail partners, or any JOTT Marketing...

  • Turquoise Explained: Origins, Pricing, and Real Vs Fake

    Turquoise Explained: Origins, Pricing, and Real...

    This is a transcript of the JOTT video "Turquoise Explained" TIMESTAMPS 00:23 How to Tell if Turquoise is Real 00:48 Chrysocolla and Turquoise Rough 3:28 Turquoise History 3:44 Stabilized Turquoise...

    Turquoise Explained: Origins, Pricing, and Real...

    This is a transcript of the JOTT video "Turquoise Explained" TIMESTAMPS 00:23 How to Tell if Turquoise is Real 00:48 Chrysocolla and Turquoise Rough 3:28 Turquoise History 3:44 Stabilized Turquoise...

  • Translucency in Jadeite Jade | The Value of Icy Jades and the Meaning of Ice and Water Jades

    Translucency in Jadeite Jade | The Value of Icy...

    Which jade has translucency? There are two gemstones that are gemologically called "jade" in the US: Nephrite Jade and Jadeite Jade. Nephrite Jade is a microcrystalline amphibole, usually tremolite, that...

    Translucency in Jadeite Jade | The Value of Icy...

    Which jade has translucency? There are two gemstones that are gemologically called "jade" in the US: Nephrite Jade and Jadeite Jade. Nephrite Jade is a microcrystalline amphibole, usually tremolite, that...

1 of 4